Choosing the right form backend for your static website is crucial for user experience and long-term maintainability. Both Netlify Forms and Static Forms are popular solutions for handling form submissions without server-side code, but they serve different needs and use cases. In this comprehensive comparison, we'll examine both services across key factors: ease of use, features, pricing, platform flexibility, and spam protection. Whether you're building a personal portfolio, a business website, or a large-scale JAMstack application, this guide will help you make an informed decision. We'll provide an honest, unbiased comparison highlighting the strengths and limitations of each service so you can choose the best solution for your specific needs. ## Quick Overview | Feature | Netlify Forms | Static Forms | |---------|---------------|--------------| | **Hosting Required** | Netlify only | Any hosting platform | | **Free Tier** | 100 submissions/month | 500 submissions/month | | **Setup Complexity** | Very simple (1 attribute) | Simple (2 fields) | | **Spam Protection** | Honeypot, Akismet (paid) | Honeypot, reCAPTCHA, Altcha | | **Email Notifications** | Yes | Yes | | **File Uploads** | Yes | Yes | | **Webhooks** | Yes (paid) | Yes (paid) | | **Works Without Netlify** | ❌ No | ✅ Yes | | **Starting Price** | $19/mo (Level 1) | $9/mo (Pro) | ## Platform Flexibility ### Netlify Forms: Netlify Hosting Required Netlify Forms is tightly integrated with Netlify's hosting platform. This has both advantages and limitations: **Pros:** - ✅ Seamless integration if you're already on Netlify - ✅ Automatic form detection during builds - ✅ Zero additional configuration needed **Cons:** - ❌ Only works on Netlify hosting - ❌ Can't use on GitHub Pages, Vercel, or traditional hosting - ❌ Vendor lock-in - switching hosts means rebuilding forms **Example - Netlify Forms Setup:** ```html ``` ### Static Forms: Platform Agnostic Static Forms works with any hosting platform that serves HTML: **Pros:** - ✅ Works on Netlify, Vercel, GitHub Pages, Cloudflare Pages - ✅ Works on traditional hosting (cPanel, shared hosting) - ✅ Works on custom infrastructure - ✅ No vendor lock-in - switch hosts anytime **Cons:** - Requires adding API endpoint and API key (2 extra fields) **Example - Static Forms Setup:** ```html ``` **Verdict:** If you're committed to Netlify hosting, Netlify Forms offers simpler setup. If you want flexibility to host anywhere, Static Forms is the clear winner. ## Ease of Setup ### Netlify Forms: Slightly Simpler Setup Netlify Forms has a marginally simpler initial setup: 1. Add `data-netlify="true"` to your form 2. Deploy to Netlify 3. Done! The build process automatically detects and configures your forms. ### Static Forms: Simple and Explicit Static Forms requires two additional elements: 1. Set form action to `https://api.staticforms.dev/submit` 2. Add your API key as a hidden field 3. Works immediately on any hosting **Verdict:** Netlify Forms wins on simplicity *if* you're already using Netlify. Static Forms is nearly as simple and works everywhere. ## Spam Protection ### Netlify Forms: Basic + Paid Options **Free Spam Protection:** - Honeypot fields (add `netlify-honeypot="bot-field"`) - Basic submission throttling **Paid Spam Protection:** - Akismet integration ($19+/month) - More aggressive filtering **Example with Honeypot:** ```html ``` ### Static Forms: Multiple Free Options **Free Spam Protection:** - Honeypot fields (built-in) - Google reCAPTCHA v2 (free) - Custom validation rules **Pro Spam Protection:** - Google reCAPTCHA v3 (invisible) - Altcha CAPTCHA (privacy-first, GDPR compliant) - Advanced rate limiting **Example with reCAPTCHA:** ```html ``` For privacy-conscious projects, Static Forms offers [Altcha CAPTCHA](/blog/implementing-altcha-captcha-html-website) - a GDPR-compliant alternative that doesn't track users. **Verdict:** Static Forms offers more spam protection options, including free reCAPTCHA and privacy-first Altcha. ## Pricing Comparison ### Netlify Forms Pricing **Free Tier:** - 100 form submissions per month - Honeypot spam filtering only - Email notifications included **Level 1 - $19/month:** - 1,000 submissions per month - Akismet spam filtering - All features included **Overage Costs:** - Additional submissions: Not clearly published ### Static Forms Pricing **Free Tier:** - 500 submissions per month - Unlimited forms - Email notifications - Honeypot + reCAPTCHA v2 - File uploads (2MB limit) **Pro - $9/month:** - 25,000 submissions per month - Everything in Free - reCAPTCHA v3 (invisible) - Altcha CAPTCHA - Webhooks - Larger file uploads (10MB) - Priority support **Enterprise - Custom Pricing:** - Custom submission limits - Dedicated support - Custom integrations - SLA guarantees ### Pricing Comparison Table | Plan | Netlify Forms | Static Forms | |------|---------------|--------------| | **Free** | 100 submissions | 500 submissions | | **Entry Paid** | $19/mo (1,000) | $9/mo (25,000) | | **Cost per 1,000** | $19 | $0.36 | | **Spam Protection** | Basic (free), Akismet (paid) | Honeypot, reCAPTCHA (free), Altcha (paid) | **Verdict:** Static Forms offers significantly better value with 500 free submissions (vs 100) and 25,000 submissions for $9/month (vs $19 for 1,000). ## Features Deep Dive ### Email Notifications **Both services:** - ✅ Send submission notifications to your email - ✅ Include all form field data - ✅ Customizable email subjects **Static Forms extras:** - ✅ Auto-responder emails (Pro) - ✅ Multiple recipient emails - ✅ Custom reply-to addresses ### File Uploads **Netlify Forms:** - Supported on all plans - File size limits depend on plan tier - Files stored on Netlify infrastructure **Static Forms:** - Supported on all plans - 2MB limit (free), 5MB (Pro) - Files delivered via email attachments - Multiple file uploads supported Learn more about implementing file uploads in our [file upload tutorial](/blog/nextjs-contact-form-document-upload). ### Webhooks & Integrations **Netlify Forms:** - Webhooks available on paid plans ($19+) - Send submissions to external services - Zapier integration available **Static Forms:** - Webhooks available on Pro ($9) - Send submissions to any HTTP endpoint - Pre-built integrations: - Slack - Discord - Google Sheets - Notion - Airtable - Zapier - Make (Integromat) - n8n ### Form Submissions Dashboard **Netlify Forms:** - Built into Netlify dashboard - View all submissions - Export to CSV - Spam filtering controls **Static Forms:** - Dedicated forms dashboard - View and manage submissions - Export functionality - Analytics and reporting - Form-specific settings ## JavaScript/AJAX Support ### Netlify Forms: Extra Configuration Needed For JavaScript-based submissions: ```javascript fetch('/', { method: 'POST', headers: { 'Content-Type': 'application/x-www-form-urlencoded' }, body: encode({ 'form-name': 'contact', ...formData }) }) ``` You also need to include a hidden HTML form for detection during build time. ### Static Forms: Works Out of the Box ```javascript fetch('https://api.staticforms.dev/submit', { method: 'POST', headers: { 'Content-Type': 'application/json' }, body: JSON.stringify(formData) }) ``` No hidden forms or special configuration needed. **Verdict:** Static Forms has simpler AJAX/JavaScript implementation. ## Framework Integration ### Netlify Forms Works well with: - ✅ Gatsby (excellent integration) - ✅ Next.js (requires special handling for static export) - ✅ Hugo, Jekyll, Eleventy - ❌ React SPAs (requires workarounds) - ❌ Vue/Nuxt SPAs (requires workarounds) ### Static Forms Works seamlessly with: - ✅ Gatsby ([full tutorial](/blog/using-staticforms-with-gatsby)) - ✅ Next.js ([full tutorial](/blog/using-staticforms-with-nextjs)) - ✅ Nuxt.js ([full tutorial](/blog/using-staticforms-with-nuxtjs)) - ✅ React, Vue, Angular, Svelte - ✅ Hugo, Jekyll, Eleventy, Astro - ✅ Plain HTML **Verdict:** Static Forms has better framework compatibility, especially for SPAs and modern frameworks. ## Privacy & GDPR Compliance ### Netlify Forms - Data stored on Netlify servers (US-based) - Subject to Netlify privacy policy - Akismet spam filtering sends data to third parties - No specific GDPR features ### Static Forms - Offers privacy-first Altcha CAPTCHA (no tracking, no cookies) - GDPR-compliant by default - Data processing transparent - No third-party tracking unless you add reCAPTCHA For privacy-conscious projects, read our guide on [GDPR-compliant contact forms](/blog/implementing-altcha-captcha-html-website). **Verdict:** Static Forms offers better privacy options with Altcha CAPTCHA. ## Use Case Recommendations ### Choose Netlify Forms If: ✅ You're already hosting on Netlify and happy with it ✅ You want the absolute simplest setup (one attribute) ✅ You need 100+ free submissions per month ✅ You're deeply integrated with Netlify's ecosystem ✅ Budget isn't a primary concern ### Choose Static Forms If: ✅ You want hosting flexibility (Vercel, GitHub Pages, etc.) ✅ You're building on multiple platforms ✅ You want affordable paid plans ($9 vs $19 with 25x more submissions) ✅ You need more spam protection options ✅ You want privacy-first CAPTCHA (Altcha) ✅ You're building SPAs or modern JavaScript frameworks ✅ You want simpler JavaScript/AJAX integration ✅ You need extensive webhook integrations ## Migration from Netlify Forms to Static Forms Switching is straightforward: **Step 1: Update your form** ```html

``` **Step 2: Add API key** ```html ``` **Step 3: Remove Netlify-specific attributes** ```html data-netlify="true" netlify-honeypot="bot-field" ``` **Step 4: Test thoroughly** before switching production traffic. That's it! Your forms will work on any hosting platform. ## Real-World Performance ### Response Times **Netlify Forms:** - Fast (integrated with hosting) - Variable depending on build process - ~200-400ms average response time **Static Forms:** - Consistently fast API endpoint - ~150-300ms average response time - Globally distributed infrastructure ### Reliability **Both services** offer excellent uptime (99.9%+). Both have proven track records with thousands of users. ## Developer Experience ### Documentation **Netlify Forms:** - ✅ Good documentation - ✅ Integrated with main Netlify docs - ❌ Limited code examples for advanced cases **Static Forms:** - ✅ Comprehensive documentation - ✅ Framework-specific tutorials - ✅ Working code examples for every use case - ✅ Active blog with tutorials ### Support **Netlify Forms:** - Community forum - Email support (paid plans) - Response times vary **Static Forms:** - Email support (all plans) - Priority support (Pro plans) - Comprehensive troubleshooting guides ## Final Verdict Both Netlify Forms and Static Forms are excellent solutions, but they serve different needs: ### Netlify Forms is Best For: - Netlify-exclusive projects - Teams already invested in Netlify ecosystem - Projects needing 100+ free submissions ### Static Forms is Best For: - Multi-platform projects - Budget-conscious developers - Privacy-focused applications - Modern JavaScript frameworks - Projects requiring hosting flexibility - Teams wanting extensive integrations ## Conclusion The choice between Netlify Forms and Static Forms depends on your specific requirements: **If you're locked into Netlify hosting** and want the absolute simplest setup, Netlify Forms is a solid choice. The one-attribute setup is hard to beat for pure simplicity. **If you value flexibility, affordability, and modern features**, Static Forms is the better option. The ability to work on any hosting platform, combined with better pricing ($9 vs $19 with 25x more submissions) and better spam protection options, makes it ideal for most projects. Both services will reliably handle your form submissions. Your decision should be based on: 1. Hosting platform flexibility needs 2. Budget constraints 3. Required features (especially spam protection) 4. Privacy requirements Ready to get started with Static Forms? [Sign up for free](https://www.staticforms.dev) and add forms to any website - whether you're on Netlify, GitHub Pages, Vercel, or anywhere else. For implementation guides, check out our tutorials for [GitHub Pages](/blog/github-pages-contact-form-tutorial), [Next.js](/blog/using-staticforms-with-nextjs), and [HTML forms](/blog/html-form-send-email-without-server).

Posts tagged “comparison”

Filter by Tag

Netlify Forms vs Static Forms: Complete Comparison